Jul 1, 2021 · In the classification problem, out-of-distribution data means data with classes not included in the training data. Detecting such out-of-distribution data is a critical problem in the stability of an image classification model using deep learning [10 ]. We define wafer map data with a form other than the 16 types of wafer maps corresponding to ... Aug 24, 2022 · We include results for four types of out-of-distribution samples: (1) dataset shift, where we evaluate the model on two other datasets with differences in the acquisition and population patterns (2) transformation shift where we apply artificial transformations to our ID data, (3) diagnostic shift, where we compare Covid-19 to non-Covid ... Oct 28, 2022 · Out-of-Distribution (OOD) detection separates ID (In-Distribution) data and OOD data from input data through a model. This problem has attracted increasing attention in the area of machine learning. OOD detection has achieved good intrusion detection, fraud detection, system health monitoring, sensor network event detection, and ecosystem interference detection. The method based on deep ... Feb 1, 2023 · TL;DR: We propose a novel out-of-distribution detection method motivated by Modern Hopfield Energy, and futhur derive a simplified version that is effective, efficient and hyperparameter-free. Abstract : Out-of-Distribution (OOD) detection is essential for safety-critical applications of deep neural networks. Dec 17, 2019 · The likelihood is dominated by the “background” pixels, whereas the likelihood ratio focuses on the “semantic” pixels and is thus better for OOD detection. Our likelihood ratio method corrects the background effect and significantly improves the OOD detection of MNIST images from an AUROC score of 0.089 to 0.994, based on a PixelCNN++ ... high-risk applications [5,6]. To solve the problem, out-of-distribution (OOD) detection aims to distinguish and reject test samples with either covariate shifts or semantic shifts or both, so as to prevent models trained on in-distribution (ID) data from producing unreliable predictions [4]. Existing OOD detection methods mostly focus on cal- out-of-distribution examples, assuming our training set only contains older defendants referred as in-dis-tribution examples. The fractions of data are only for illustrative purposes. See details of in-distribution vs. out-of-distribution setup in §3.2. assistance, human-AI teams should outperform AI alone and human alone (e.g., in accuracy; also Mar 2, 2020 · Out-of-Distribution Generalization via Risk Extrapolation (REx) Distributional shift is one of the major obstacles when transferring machine learning prediction systems from the lab to the real world. To tackle this problem, we assume that variation across training domains is representative of the variation we might encounter at test time, but ... Mar 3, 2021 · Then, we focus on a certain class of out of distribution problems, their assumptions, and introduce simple algorithms that follow from these assumptions that are able to provide more reliable generalization. A central topic in the thesis is the strong link between discovering the causal structure of the data, finding features that are reliable ... Evaluation under Distribution Shifts. Measure, Explore, and Exploit Data Heterogeneity. Distributionally Robust Optimization. Applications of OOD Generalization & Heterogeneity. I am looking for undergraduates to collaborate with. If you are interested in performance evaluation, robust learning, out-of-distribution generalization, etc. A Simple Unified Framework for Detecting Out-of-Distribution Samples and Adversarial Attacks. Detecting test samples drawn sufficiently far away from the training distribution statistically or adversarially is a fundamental requirement for deploying a good classifier in many real-world machine learning applications. The outputs of an ensemble of networks can be used to estimate the uncertainty of a classifier. At test time, the estimated uncertainty for out-of-distribution samples turns out to be higher than the one for in-distribution samples. 3. level 2. AnvaMiba. Jun 1, 2022 · In part I, we considered the case where we have a clean set of unlabelled data and must determine if a new sample comes from the same set. In part II, we considered the open-set recognition scenario where we also have class labels. This is particularly relevant to the real-world deployment of classifiers, which will inevitably encounter OOD data. examples of 2 in-distribution (from CIFAR-100) and 1 out-of-distribution class (from CIFAR-10). The color coding shows the Mahalanobis outlier score, while the points are projections of embeddings of members of the in-distribution CIFAR-100 classes "sunflowers" (black plus signs) and "turtle" To clarify the distinction between in-stock distribution, out-of-stock (OOS) distribution, and loss of distribution, it is essential to understand the dynamics of product availability and stock levels. Let’s refer to Exhibit 29.14, which provides an example of a brand’s incidence of purchase and stocks across four time periods. examples of 2 in-distribution (from CIFAR-100) and 1 out-of-distribution class (from CIFAR-10). The color coding shows the Mahalanobis outlier score, while the points are projections of embeddings of members of the in-distribution CIFAR-100 classes "sunflowers" (black plus signs) and "turtle" Mar 25, 2022 · All solutions mentioned above, such as regularization, multimodality, scaling, and invariant risk minimization, can improve distribution shift and out-of-distribution generalization, ultimately ... Jan 22, 2019 · Out-of-distribution detection using an ensemble of self supervised leave-out classifiers A. Vyas, N. Jammalamadaka, X. Zhu, D. Das, B. Kaul, and T. L. Willke, “Out-of-distribution detection using an ensemble of self supervised leave-out classifiers,” in European Conference on Computer Vision, 2018, pp. 560–574. Sep 15, 2022 · The unique contribution of this paper is two-fold, justified by extensive experiments. First, we present a realistic problem setting of OOD task for skin lesion. Second, we propose an approach to target the long-tailed and fine-grained aspects of the problem setting simultaneously to increase the OOD performance. However, using GANs to detect out-of-distribution instances by measuring the likelihood under the data distribution can fail (Nalisnick et al.,2019), while VAEs often generate ambiguous and blurry explanations. More recently, some re-searchers have argued that using auxiliary generative models in counterfactual generation incurs an engineering ... May 15, 2022 · 1. We propose an unsupervised method to distinguish in-distribution from out-of-distribution input. The results indicate that the assumptions and methods of outlier and deep anomaly detection are also relevant to the field of out-of-distribution detection. 2. The method works on the basis of an Isolation Forest. Dec 25, 2020 · Out-of-Distribution Detection in Deep Neural Networks Outline:. A bit on OOD. The term “distribution” has slightly different meanings for Language and Vision tasks. Consider a dog... Approaches to Detect OOD instances:. One class of OOD detection techniques is based on thresholding over the ... Feb 19, 2023 · Abstract. Recently, out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization has attracted attention to the robustness and generalization ability of deep learning based models, and accordingly, many strategies have been made to address different aspects related to this issue. However, most existing algorithms for OOD generalization are complicated and ... Mar 3, 2021 · Then, we focus on a certain class of out of distribution problems, their assumptions, and introduce simple algorithms that follow from these assumptions that are able to provide more reliable generalization. A central topic in the thesis is the strong link between discovering the causal structure of the data, finding features that are reliable ... out-of-distribution. We present a simple baseline that utilizes probabilities from softmax distributions. Correctly classified examples tend to have greater maxi-mum softmax probabilities than erroneously classified and out-of-distribution ex-amples, allowing for their detection. We assess performance by defining sev- Aug 24, 2022 · We include results for four types of out-of-distribution samples: (1) dataset shift, where we evaluate the model on two other datasets with differences in the acquisition and population patterns (2) transformation shift where we apply artificial transformations to our ID data, (3) diagnostic shift, where we compare Covid-19 to non-Covid ... Oct 28, 2022 · Out-of-Distribution (OOD) detection separates ID (In-Distribution) data and OOD data from input data through a model. This problem has attracted increasing attention in the area of machine learning. OOD detection has achieved good intrusion detection, fraud detection, system health monitoring, sensor network event detection, and ecosystem interference detection. The method based on deep ... Dec 17, 2020 · While deep learning demonstrates its strong ability to handle independent and identically distributed (IID) data, it often suffers from out-of-distribution (OoD) generalization, where the test data come from another distribution (w.r.t. the training one). Designing a general OoD generalization framework to a wide range of applications is challenging, mainly due to possible correlation shift ... Jan 25, 2021 · The term 'out-of-distribution' (OOD) data refers to data that was collected at a different time, and possibly under different conditions or in a different environment, then the data collected to create the model. They may say that this data is from a 'different distribution'. Data that is in-distribution can be called novelty data. CVF Open Access Jun 6, 2021 · Near out-of-distribution detection (OOD) is a major challenge for deep neural networks. We demonstrate that large-scale pre-trained transformers can significantly improve the state-of-the-art (SOTA) on a range of near OOD tasks across different data modalities. For instance, on CIFAR-100 vs CIFAR-10 OOD detection, we improve the AUROC from 85% (current SOTA) to more than 96% using Vision ... Feb 1, 2023 · TL;DR: We propose a novel out-of-distribution detection method motivated by Modern Hopfield Energy, and futhur derive a simplified version that is effective, efficient and hyperparameter-free. Abstract : Out-of-Distribution (OOD) detection is essential for safety-critical applications of deep neural networks. examples of 2 in-distribution (from CIFAR-100) and 1 out-of-distribution class (from CIFAR-10). The color coding shows the Mahalanobis outlier score, while the points are projections of embeddings of members of the in-distribution CIFAR-100 classes "sunflowers" (black plus signs) and "turtle" out-of-distribution examples, assuming our training set only contains older defendants referred as in-dis-tribution examples. The fractions of data are only for illustrative purposes. See details of in-distribution vs. out-of-distribution setup in §3.2. assistance, human-AI teams should outperform AI alone and human alone (e.g., in accuracy; also ODIN: Out-of-Distribution Detector for Neural Networks Apr 16, 2021 · Deep Stable Learning for Out-Of-Distribution Generalization. Xingxuan Zhang, Peng Cui, Renzhe Xu, Linjun Zhou, Yue He, Zheyan Shen. Approaches based on deep neural networks have achieved striking performance when testing data and training data share similar distribution, but can significantly fail otherwise. Therefore, eliminating the impact of ... out-of-distribution examples, assuming our training set only contains older defendants referred as in-dis-tribution examples. The fractions of data are only for illustrative purposes. See details of in-distribution vs. out-of-distribution setup in §3.2. assistance, human-AI teams should outperform AI alone and human alone (e.g., in accuracy; also Dec 17, 2020 · While deep learning demonstrates its strong ability to handle independent and identically distributed (IID) data, it often suffers from out-of-distribution (OoD) generalization, where the test data come from another distribution (w.r.t. the training one). Designing a general OoD generalization framework to a wide range of applications is challenging, mainly due to possible correlation shift ... this to be out-of-distribution clustering. Once a model Mhas been trained on the class homogeneity task, we can evaluate it for both out-of-distribution classification and out-of-distribution clustering. For the former, in which we are given x~ from a sample-label pair (~x;~y j~y = 2Y train), we can classify x~ by comparing it with samples of Jun 1, 2022 · In part I, we considered the case where we have a clean set of unlabelled data and must determine if a new sample comes from the same set. In part II, we considered the open-set recognition scenario where we also have class labels. This is particularly relevant to the real-world deployment of classifiers, which will inevitably encounter OOD data. The outputs of an ensemble of networks can be used to estimate the uncertainty of a classifier. At test time, the estimated uncertainty for out-of-distribution samples turns out to be higher than the one for in-distribution samples. 3. level 2. AnvaMiba. While out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization, robustness, and detection have been discussed in works related to reducing existential risks from AI (e.g., [Amodei et al., 2016, Hendrycks et al., 2022b]) the truth is that the vast majority of distribution shifts are not directly related to existential risks. Dec 17, 2020 · While deep learning demonstrates its strong ability to handle independent and identically distributed (IID) data, it often suffers from out-of-distribution (OoD) generalization, where the test data come from another distribution (w.r.t. the training one). Designing a general OoD generalization framework to a wide range of applications is challenging, mainly due to possible correlation shift ... It is well known that fine-tuning leads to better accuracy in-distribution (ID). However, in this paper, we find that fine-tuning can achieve worse accuracy than linear probing out-of-distribution (OOD) when the pretrained features are good and the distribution shift is large. On 10 distribution shift datasets The outputs of an ensemble of networks can be used to estimate the uncertainty of a classifier. At test time, the estimated uncertainty for out-of-distribution samples turns out to be higher than the one for in-distribution samples. 3. level 2. AnvaMiba. this to be out-of-distribution clustering. Once a model Mhas been trained on the class homogeneity task, we can evaluate it for both out-of-distribution classification and out-of-distribution clustering. For the former, in which we are given x~ from a sample-label pair (~x;~y j~y = 2Y train), we can classify x~ by comparing it with samples of Feb 19, 2023 · Abstract. Recently, out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization has attracted attention to the robustness and generalization ability of deep learning based models, and accordingly, many strategies have been made to address different aspects related to this issue. However, most existing algorithms for OOD generalization are complicated and ... Sep 15, 2022 · The unique contribution of this paper is two-fold, justified by extensive experiments. First, we present a realistic problem setting of OOD task for skin lesion. Second, we propose an approach to target the long-tailed and fine-grained aspects of the problem setting simultaneously to increase the OOD performance. A Simple Unified Framework for Detecting Out-of-Distribution Samples and Adversarial Attacks. Detecting test samples drawn sufficiently far away from the training distribution statistically or adversarially is a fundamental requirement for deploying a good classifier in many real-world machine learning applications. ODIN: Out-of-Distribution Detector for Neural Networks Jan 25, 2021 · The term 'out-of-distribution' (OOD) data refers to data that was collected at a different time, and possibly under different conditions or in a different environment, then the data collected to create the model. They may say that this data is from a 'different distribution'. Data that is in-distribution can be called novelty data. out-of-distribution examples, assuming our training set only contains older defendants referred as in-dis-tribution examples. The fractions of data are only for illustrative purposes. See details of in-distribution vs. out-of-distribution setup in §3.2. assistance, human-AI teams should outperform AI alone and human alone (e.g., in accuracy; also out-of-distribution. We present a simple baseline that utilizes probabilities from softmax distributions. Correctly classified examples tend to have greater maxi-mum softmax probabilities than erroneously classified and out-of-distribution ex-amples, allowing for their detection. We assess performance by defining sev- Mar 3, 2021 · Then, we focus on a certain class of out of distribution problems, their assumptions, and introduce simple algorithms that follow from these assumptions that are able to provide more reliable generalization. A central topic in the thesis is the strong link between discovering the causal structure of the data, finding features that are reliable ... cause of model crash under distribution shifts, they propose to realize out-of-distribution generalization by decorrelat-ing the relevant and irrelevant features. Since there is no extra supervision for separating relevant features from ir-relevant features, a conservative solution is to decorrelate all features. Apr 19, 2023 · Recently, a class of compact and brain-inspired continuous-time recurrent neural networks has shown great promise in modeling autonomous navigation of ground ( 18, 19) and simulated drone vehicles end to end in a closed loop with their environments ( 21 ). These networks are called liquid time-constant (LTC) networks ( 35 ), or liquid networks. While out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization, robustness, and detection have been discussed in works related to reducing existential risks from AI (e.g., [Amodei et al., 2016, Hendrycks et al., 2022b]) the truth is that the vast majority of distribution shifts are not directly related to existential risks. A Simple Unified Framework for Detecting Out-of-Distribution Samples and Adversarial Attacks. Detecting test samples drawn sufficiently far away from the training distribution statistically or adversarially is a fundamental requirement for deploying a good classifier in many real-world machine learning applications. Aug 31, 2021 · This paper represents the first comprehensive, systematic review of OOD generalization, encompassing a spectrum of aspects from problem definition, methodological development, and evaluation procedures, to the implications and future directions of the field. trained in the closed-world setting, the out-of-distribution (OOD) issue arises and deteriorates customer experience when the models are deployed in production, facing inputs comingfromtheopenworld[9]. Forinstance,amodelmay wrongly but confidently classify an image of crab into the clappingclass,eventhoughnocrab-relatedconceptsappear in the ... To clarify the distinction between in-stock distribution, out-of-stock (OOS) distribution, and loss of distribution, it is essential to understand the dynamics of product availability and stock levels. Let’s refer to Exhibit 29.14, which provides an example of a brand’s incidence of purchase and stocks across four time periods. Aug 29, 2023 · ODIN is a preprocessing method for inputs that aims to increase the discriminability of the softmax outputs for In- and Out-of-Distribution data. Implements the Mahalanobis Method. Implements the Energy Score of Energy-based Out-of-distribution Detection. Uses entropy to detect OOD inputs. Implements the MaxLogit method. Feb 21, 2022 · Most existing datasets with category and viewpoint labels 13,26,27,28 present two major challenges: (1) lack of control over the distribution of categories and viewpoints, or (2) small size. Thus ... [ICML2022] Breaking Down Out-of-Distribution Detection: Many Methods Based on OOD Training Data Estimate a Combination of the Same Core Quantities [ICML2022] Scaling Out-of-Distribution Detection for Real-World Settings [ICML2022] POEM: Out-of-Distribution Detection with Posterior Sampling [NeurIPS2022] Deep Ensembles Work, But Are They Necessary? Nov 26, 2021 · Unsupervised out-of-distribution (U-OOD) detection has recently attracted much attention due its importance in mission-critical systems and broader applicability over its supervised counterpart. Despite this increase in attention, U-OOD methods suffer from important shortcomings. By performing a large-scale evaluation on different benchmarks and image modalities, we show in this work that most ... Feb 16, 2022 · Graph machine learning has been extensively studied in both academia and industry. Although booming with a vast number of emerging methods and techniques, most of the literature is built on the in-distribution hypothesis, i.e., testing and training graph data are identically distributed. However, this in-distribution hypothesis can hardly be satisfied in many real-world graph scenarios where ... marginal distribution of P X,Y for the input variable Xby P 0.Given a test input x ∈X, the problem of out-of-distribution detection can be formulated as a single-sample hypothesis testing task: H 0: x ∼P 0, vs. H 1: x ≁P 0. (1) Here the null hypothesis H 0 implies that the test input x is an in-distribution sample. The goal of Hendrycks & Gimpel proposed a baseline method to detect out-of-distribution examples without further re-training networks. The method is based on an observation that a well-trained neural network tends to assign higher softmax scores to in-distribution examples than out-of-distribution Work done while at Cornell University. 1 Dec 17, 2019 · The likelihood is dominated by the “background” pixels, whereas the likelihood ratio focuses on the “semantic” pixels and is thus better for OOD detection. Our likelihood ratio method corrects the background effect and significantly improves the OOD detection of MNIST images from an AUROC score of 0.089 to 0.994, based on a PixelCNN++ ... cannot deliver reliable reasoning results when facing out-of-distribution samples. Next, even if supervision signals can be properly propagated between the neural and symbolic models, it is still possible that the NN predicts spurious fea-tures, leading to bad generalization performance (an exam-ple is provided in Sec. 6). Apr 19, 2023 · Recently, a class of compact and brain-inspired continuous-time recurrent neural networks has shown great promise in modeling autonomous navigation of ground ( 18, 19) and simulated drone vehicles end to end in a closed loop with their environments ( 21 ). These networks are called liquid time-constant (LTC) networks ( 35 ), or liquid networks. Dec 25, 2020 · Out-of-Distribution Detection in Deep Neural Networks Outline:. A bit on OOD. The term “distribution” has slightly different meanings for Language and Vision tasks. Consider a dog... Approaches to Detect OOD instances:. One class of OOD detection techniques is based on thresholding over the ... novelty detection (ND), open set recognition (OSR), out-of-distribution (OOD) detection, and outlier detection (OD). These sub-topics can be similar in the sense that they all define a certain in-distribution, with the common goal of detecting out-of-distribution samples under the open-world assumption. However, subtle differences exist among ... Oct 28, 2022 · Out-of-Distribution (OOD) detection separates ID (In-Distribution) data and OOD data from input data through a model. This problem has attracted increasing attention in the area of machine learning. OOD detection has achieved good intrusion detection, fraud detection, system health monitoring, sensor network event detection, and ecosystem interference detection. The method based on deep ... We evaluate our method on a diverse set of in- and out-of-distribution dataset pairs. In many settings, our method outperforms other methods by a large margin. The contri-butions of our paper are summarized as follows: • We propose a novel experimental setting and a novel training methodology for out-of-distribution detection in neural networks. Out-of-Distribution (OOD) Detection with Deep Neural Networks based on PyTorch. and is designed such that it should be compatible with frameworks like pytorch-lightning and pytorch-segmentation-models . The library also covers some methods from closely related fields such as Open-Set Recognition, Novelty Detection, Confidence Estimation and ... trained in the closed-world setting, the out-of-distribution (OOD) issue arises and deteriorates customer experience when the models are deployed in production, facing inputs comingfromtheopenworld[9]. Forinstance,amodelmay wrongly but confidently classify an image of crab into the clappingclass,eventhoughnocrab-relatedconceptsappear in the ... ing data distribution p(x;y). At inference time, given an input x02Xthe goal of OOD detection is to identify whether x0is a sample drawn from p(x;y). 2.2 Types of Distribution Shifts As in (Ren et al.,2019), we assume that any repre-sentation of the input x, ˚(x), can be decomposed into two independent and disjoint components: the background ...
Jul 1, 2021 · In the classification problem, out-of-distribution data means data with classes not included in the training data. Detecting such out-of-distribution data is a critical problem in the stability of an image classification model using deep learning [10 ]. We define wafer map data with a form other than the 16 types of wafer maps corresponding to ... . Ecdbd
Jul 1, 2021 · In general, out-of-distribution data refers to data having a distribution different from that of training data. In the classification problem, out-of-distribution means data with classes that are not included in the training data. In image classification using the deep neural network, the research has been actively conducted to improve the ... Jul 1, 2021 · In general, out-of-distribution data refers to data having a distribution different from that of training data. In the classification problem, out-of-distribution means data with classes that are not included in the training data. In image classification using the deep neural network, the research has been actively conducted to improve the ... out-of-distribution examples, assuming our training set only contains older defendants referred as in-dis-tribution examples. The fractions of data are only for illustrative purposes. See details of in-distribution vs. out-of-distribution setup in §3.2. assistance, human-AI teams should outperform AI alone and human alone (e.g., in accuracy; also Jan 25, 2021 · The term 'out-of-distribution' (OOD) data refers to data that was collected at a different time, and possibly under different conditions or in a different environment, then the data collected to create the model. They may say that this data is from a 'different distribution'. Data that is in-distribution can be called novelty data. Mar 2, 2020 · Out-of-Distribution Generalization via Risk Extrapolation (REx) Distributional shift is one of the major obstacles when transferring machine learning prediction systems from the lab to the real world. To tackle this problem, we assume that variation across training domains is representative of the variation we might encounter at test time, but ... To clarify the distinction between in-stock distribution, out-of-stock (OOS) distribution, and loss of distribution, it is essential to understand the dynamics of product availability and stock levels. Let’s refer to Exhibit 29.14, which provides an example of a brand’s incidence of purchase and stocks across four time periods. Sep 15, 2022 · The unique contribution of this paper is two-fold, justified by extensive experiments. First, we present a realistic problem setting of OOD task for skin lesion. Second, we propose an approach to target the long-tailed and fine-grained aspects of the problem setting simultaneously to increase the OOD performance. Aug 29, 2023 · ODIN is a preprocessing method for inputs that aims to increase the discriminability of the softmax outputs for In- and Out-of-Distribution data. Implements the Mahalanobis Method. Implements the Energy Score of Energy-based Out-of-distribution Detection. Uses entropy to detect OOD inputs. Implements the MaxLogit method. Mar 2, 2020 · Out-of-Distribution Generalization via Risk Extrapolation (REx) Distributional shift is one of the major obstacles when transferring machine learning prediction systems from the lab to the real world. To tackle this problem, we assume that variation across training domains is representative of the variation we might encounter at test time, but ... Feb 21, 2022 · It is well known that fine-tuning leads to better accuracy in-distribution (ID). However, in this paper, we find that fine-tuning can achieve worse accuracy than linear probing out-of-distribution (OOD) when the pretrained features are good and the distribution shift is large. On 10 distribution shift datasets (Breeds-Living17, Breeds-Entity30 ... The outputs of an ensemble of networks can be used to estimate the uncertainty of a classifier. At test time, the estimated uncertainty for out-of-distribution samples turns out to be higher than the one for in-distribution samples. 3. level 2. AnvaMiba. Feb 16, 2022 · Graph machine learning has been extensively studied in both academia and industry. Although booming with a vast number of emerging methods and techniques, most of the literature is built on the in-distribution hypothesis, i.e., testing and training graph data are identically distributed. However, this in-distribution hypothesis can hardly be satisfied in many real-world graph scenarios where ... May 15, 2022 · 1. We propose an unsupervised method to distinguish in-distribution from out-of-distribution input. The results indicate that the assumptions and methods of outlier and deep anomaly detection are also relevant to the field of out-of-distribution detection. 2. The method works on the basis of an Isolation Forest. Feb 16, 2022 · Graph machine learning has been extensively studied in both academia and industry. Although booming with a vast number of emerging methods and techniques, most of the literature is built on the in-distribution hypothesis, i.e., testing and training graph data are identically distributed. However, this in-distribution hypothesis can hardly be satisfied in many real-world graph scenarios where ... We have summarized the main branches of works for Out-of-Distribution(OOD) Generalization problem, which are classified according to the research focus, including unsupervised representation learning, supervised learning models and optimization methods. For more details, please refer to our survey on OOD generalization. .